The Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed United India General Insurance to pay ₹87.33 lakh to Mateshri Textiles, a Solapur-based textile manufacturer, after rejecting the insurer’s grounds for repudiating a fire claim. The factory, insured under three policies with a combined sum insured of ₹91.50 lakh, suffered a fire on 21 July 2017 caused by an electrical short circuit. The insurer later rejected the ₹87,33,324 claim, citing unauthorised construction, an unauthorised electricity connection and the absence of fire-fighting equipment. The Commission noted that the insurer had inspected and photographed the premises before issuing the policies and accepting premiums.

The Commission held that the insurer could not rely on such pre-existing conditions to reject the claim without establishing their causal connection with the fire or showing deliberate concealment that materially changed the insured risk. It ordered payment of the ₹87.33 lakh claim with 9% annual interest from 16 July 2018, along with ₹1 lakh compensation and ₹50,000 litigation costs. The case highlights an important claims-management principle: insurers need to distinguish between a technical or regulatory deficiency and a breach that actually contributes to the insured loss. For commercial fire insurance, thorough pre-policy inspection, clear warranties and documented risk conditions are therefore critical for both underwriting and claims decisions.

Want to deepen your expertise beyond today’s news?

Explore practical certification courses designed for banking, risk, insurance, compliance, ESG, AI, and emerging technologies professionals.

Learn from industry experts and earn certifications from RMAI and BFSI Sector Skill Council of India.

#Insurancenews

Author

Byadmin