Ramesh Kanji Cham owned a motor vessel named “Miraj”, which he used in the shipping business to transport materials. Cham insured the boat with National Insurance from February 8, 1997, to February 7, 1998.

On May 11, 1997, the vessel, which was docked at Abra Berth near Deira in Dubai Creek, keeled over on its left side. Upon learning about the mishap, Cham immediately notified the insurer and later submitted all the requisite documents. He registered a Marine Hull claim for DHS 7.56 lakh (about Rs. 73 lakh).

After five years of protracted correspondence, the insurer offered to pay only Rs. 21.44 lakh. Cham requested that this amount be released as an interim payment and sought reimbursement of the full claim of Rs. 73 lakh. Upon receiving the Rs. 21.44 lakh, he protested against the short fall and requested a detailed computation and an explanation for the deduction. The insurer responded that it had re-examined the claim and had settled it in accordance with the surveyor’s assessment.

Aggrieved, Cham approached the Gujarat State Commission, alleging that the remaining Rs. 52 lakh had been wrongly withheld by adopting unfair trade practices. He stated that although he had protested against the shortfall in payment, he had signed the discharge voucher due to financial constraints.

Author

This entry is part 24 of 25 in the series July 2025 - Insurance Times

Byadmin